STUDY SHOWS TEENS IGNORE SAFE DRIVING, CELL PHONE LAWS

FOX News.com
We Report. You Decide.
SEARCH
UREPORT
Send us your video,
photos and news
On FOX News CHANNEL:
COST OF FREEDOM

The Weekly Business Wrap-Up! (4:00am EST)
View Schedule

* Home
* U.S.
* World
* Politics
* Business
* Health
* SciTech
* Entertainment
* Video
* Opinion
* uReport
* Sports
* Weather

* RADIO
* MOBILE
* FOX & Friends
* Live Desk
* Studio B
* Your World
* Special Report
* FOX Report
* O'Reilly Factor
* Hannity & Colmes
* On the Record
* FNC iMag
* FOX Fan

Click Here
Politics

* Politics HOME
* FOX Polls
* America's Election HQ
* Eye on the Issues
* Special Report
* Fox News Sunday
* Executive Branch
* U.S. Senate
* House of Representatives
* Supreme Court
* State & Local Government
* U.S. Military
* NEWS ARCHIVE
* HOT TOPICS
o FOX News Election Coverage
o Celebrity Gossip
o FOX Movietone News
* SECTION MAP

Send news tip to FOXNews.com
SUBMIT
FOXNEWS.COM HOME > POLITICS
Study Shows Teens Ignore Safe Driving, Cell Phone Laws

Monday, June 09, 2008

* E-Mail
* Print

* Share:
o Digg
o Facebook
o StumbleUpon
o MySpace
o

WASHINGTON — From Jeannie Harrison's perspective, the social lives of most teenagers tend to revolve around their cell phones -- even when they are behind the wheel.

"People don't want to be inaccessible for even 15 minutes driving up the street," said Harrison, 19, a sophomore at Marshall University in Huntington, W.Va. "They're so used to being accessible all the time."

Targeting inexperienced motorists, several states have passed laws during the past five years restricting cell phone use by teenage drivers.

But an insurance industry study being released Monday that looked at whether teens are ignoring such restrictions contends enforcement and parental influence are just as important as new laws.

NOTE: USING OF CELL PHONES WHILE DRIVING IS INDEED RISKY.

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety studied North Carolina's law, enacted in 2006, which fines motorists under age 18 who are caught using a cell phone.

Researchers who watched as high school students left school found that teenage drivers used their cell phones at about the same rate both before and after the law took effect. In South Carolina, which does not have a similar restriction, cell phone use by teenage drivers was about the same for both periods studied.

A separate phone survey of North Carolina parents and teenagers showed widespread support for their state's law, but more than three in five reported that enforcement was rare or nonexistent.

"Cell phone bans for teen drivers are difficult to enforce," said Anne McCartt, the institute's senior vice president for research and an author of the study. "Drivers with phones to their ears aren't hard to spot, but it's nearly impossible for police officers to see handsfree devices or correctly guess how old drivers are."

Motor vehicle crashes are the leading cause of death for teenagers, according to the government's auto safety agency, and teenagers are involved in three times as many fatal crashes as all other drivers.

The institute says 17 states and the District of Columbia have cell phone restrictions in licensing requirements for teen drivers. The National Transportation Safety Board in 2003 recommended that states limit or bar young drivers from using cell phones, leading many states to act.

Harrison, who serves with Students Against Destructive Decisions, an advocacy group focused on highway safety issues, said few of her friends know about West Virginia's law banning cell phone use by novice drivers.

NOTE: THE LAW MUST BE WELL KNOWN TO ALL CONCERNED.

Bill Bronrott, a Maryland state delegate who sponsored a successful bill in 2005 prohibiting rookie drivers under 18 from using cell phones, except to make 911 emergency calls, said a "combination of education and enforcement" was critical. So, too, parental involvement.

Added Barbara Harsha, executive director of the Governors Highway Safety Association: "What these kinds of laws do is send the message to the parent more than anything else."

In the North Carolina study, researchers found that 11 percent of teenage drivers observed departing 25 high schools during the two months before the ban took effect were using cell phones. About five months after the ban took effect, during the spring of 2007, nearly 12 percent were observed using phones.

In South Carolina, observers found that 13 percent of high school students departing 18 high schools used cell phones while driving. The rates were consistent during the same two time periods studied in North Carolina.

In the North Carolina phone survey, 95 percent of parents and 74 percent of teenagers supported the restriction. But 71 percent of teens and 60 percent of parents felt that enforcement was rare or nonexistent.

In North Carolina, 37 citations were issued in 2007 by the state highway patrol to teens using a cell phone while operating a vehicle. Twenty-eight citations have been issued in 2008.

Selena Childs, executive director of the North Carolina Child Fatality Task Force, said in an e-mail that with many child safety laws in the state, "knowing that it's against the law is enough for many people to choose to comply with a law."

Childs said the state's driver's license system for young drivers has been effective "not so much because of law enforcement/citations, but because parents and teens self-enforce the law, resulting in reduced crashes."

Matt Sundeen, a transportation analyst with the National Conference of State Legislatures, said many state laws on cell phones are new, making it difficult to assess their impact. He said more states are considering similar restrictions.

The institute conducted two separate telephone surveys in North Carolina: the first, before the cell phone restriction took effect, was in November 2006 and involved 400 pairs of parents and teenagers; the second, after the law had taken effect, was in April 2007 and involved a different sample of 401 pairs of parents and teenagers. Each survey had a margin of sampling error of plus or minus 5 percentage points.

* See Next Story in Politics

* E-Mail
* Print

* Share:
o Digg
o Facebook
o StumbleUpon
o MySpace
o

Fox News Video
Top Video
Out With a Bang

Supreme Court wraps up term with historic ruling on Second Amendment
Politics

* The press and the Clinton-Obama drama
* John McCain 'up' for fundraising
* Pregnancy pact coverage
* Candidates on gun ruling

ADVERTISEMENT
Republican Presidential Nomination

RCP Average: McCain +30.4%

* McCain
* 56.7%
* Huckabee
* 26.3%
* Paul
* 6.5%

Poll Details >
Democratic Presidential Nomination

RCP Average: Obama +12.2%

* Obama
* 52.8%
* Clinton
* 40.6%

Poll Details >
President Bush Job Approval

RCP Average: Spread -39.2%

* Approve
* 28.3%
* Disapprove
* 67.5%

Poll Details >
Congressional Job Approval

RCP Average: Spread -55.0%

* Approve
* 18.5%
* Disapprove
* 73.5%

Poll Details >

* Most Read
* Top Emailed
* Top Videos

* Teen Decapitated by Batman Ride at Georgia Six Flags
* Swim Veteran Says Sport Awash in Doping as Olympic Records Fall
* Cover Model Dies in Fall From New York Building
* Uncle of Missing Girl Arrested On Unrelated Sex Charges
* Will Smith's $150 Million Disaster
* Medical Choppers Collide Over Arizona, Killing 6
* Grizzly Mauls Teen During Alaska Bike Race
* 16 Accidentally Wounded by French Military in Shooting Demo
* Giant Saudi Field is Key to Boosting Oil Output
* Pranksters Reveal Secret of Infamous Student Stunt
* Report: U.S. Escalating Covert Operations Against Iran
* Three Drown in Kern River in California
* Tennis Champ Justin Gimelstob Says He Wants to Make Anna Kournikova Cry
* College Student Murder Suspect Amanda Knox Boasts In Jailhouse Diary of Fan Mail From Men
* 74-Year-Old Florida Woman Mauled to Death by Her Two Dogs
* After Being Stabbed 22 Times, New York Man's Last Words Name Alleged Killer

* Will Smith's $150 Million Disaster
* 74-Year-Old Florida Woman Mauled to Death by Her Two Dogs
* Ancient Japanese 'Naked Sushi' Tradition Catches On in Florida
* Teen Decapitated by Batman Ride at Georgia Six Flags
* University of Georgia Mascot Dies of Heart Failure
* Report: U.S. Escalating Covert Operations Against Iran
* Report: U.K. Doctors Genetically Select Cancer-Free Child
* Giant Saudi Field is Key to Boosting Oil Output
* Grizzly Mauls Teen During Alaska Bike Race
* 16 Accidentally Wounded by French Military in Shooting Demo

* New game show for cats and owners
* The press and the Clinton-Obama drama
* Historic ruling on Second Amendment
* Historic news events of June 29-July 5
* Should North Korea be taken off list?
* Dogs compete in surfing competition
* Candidates on gun ruling
* Pregnancy pact coverage

* John McCain 'up' for fundraising
* Teen decapitated at amusement park


ADVERTISEMENT

* U.S.
* World
* Politics
* Health
* SciTech
* Entertainment

AP Wires

* Medicare fees to doctors fall Tuesday
* Today on the presidential campaign trail
* Ret. Gen. Clark: McCain lacks command experience
* China resists bid for Zimbabwe sanctions
* Obama gets in works out, hair cut, hoops
* Group with Clinton connections ready to back Obama
* Sen. Kerry facing first Democratic foe in decades
* McCain meets with evangelist Billy Graham and son
* China resists US push for UN to punish Zimbabwe
* McCain on the defensive about spending
* News Archive


Marketplace

* Autos
* Mortgages
* Personals
* Relationships

Find a Car
Find Love
Find a Date
Find a Mortgage
Get Voicemail
Free Credit Score
Fox News Shop
Credit Report
Celebrity News
Try Vonage Try Vonage!

SEARCH
News Alerts RSS Feeds Podcasts Make FOXNews.com Your Home Page Careers

* Home
* U.S.
* World
* Politics
* FOX News Polls
* Business
* Health
* SciTech
* Entertainment
* Video
* Opinion
* uReport
* Sports
* Weather

* Radio
* Mobile
* FOX & Friends
* Live Desk
* Studio B
* Your World
* Special Report
* FOX Report
* O'Reilly Factor
* Hannity & Colmes
* On the Record
* RedEye
* FNC iMag
* FOX Fan
* News Archive
* FOX Around The World
* FOX Sports
* Contact US
* Upgrade Central
* FAQs

Advertise on Fox News Channel, FOXNews.com and FOX News Radio. Advertising Specifications (PDF). Jobs at FOX News Channel. Internships At Fox News (Deadline for summer applications: Feb. 29, 2008)

Terms of use. Privacy Statement. For FOXNews.com comments write to foxnewsonline@foxnews.com; For FOX News Channel comments write to yourcomments@foxnews.com

This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. © 2008 FOX News Network, LLC. All rights reserved. All market data delayed 20 minutes.